All prices were accurate at the time of publishing. My personal favorite is the $5 clear glass gingerbread house cookie jar, which shoppers couldn’t get enough of when it hit shelves in October 2023.

Oh, what's that — you forgot to get a candy bowl? Well, we still have a few weeks until Halloween, so there's time to remedy that. Our suggestion? The Anchor Hocking Pumpkin Jar, which just so ...